Live Analyst Rating Changes 8035 upgrades, downgrades & price-target moves · freshest Wall Street data, updated daily View live feed →
Analyst Tracker/Matthew Carletti
CJ
Matthew Carletti
Citizens JMP
Wall Street Analyst
★★★☆☆
#1382
on 13Foresight · ranked by our own returns
65%
Success Rate
+10.4%
Average Return
26 of 40 calls profitable · -3.6% vs benchmark
📈 Across the calls we could measure, roughly 65% of Matthew Carletti's ratings turned a profit when each position was held for 1 year — averaging +10.4% per rating. These figures are computed by 13Foresight from historical prices, not supplied by the analyst.

Rating Distribution

57 Buy 9 Hold 0 Sell
Matthew's Stock Coverage 39 ratings · 2026-07-12
Company Date Position Consensus ⓘ Price Target ⓘ 1-Yr Return
THG
Hanover Insurance
 Jul 10, 2026 BUY Buy
-5.9% avg upside
9 analysts
$225.00
5.19% Upside
 ·
HG
Hamilton Insurance Group, Ltd. Class B
 Jul 10, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
-4.3% avg upside
9 analysts
$40.00
15.60% Upside
 +0.0%
PLGO
Pelagos Insurance Capital
 Jul 10, 2026 BUY Hold
-10.4% avg upside
12 analysts
$28.00
11.72% Upside
 ·
BRO
Brown & Brown
 Jul 10, 2026 BUY Buy
+11.9% avg upside
25 analysts
$78.00
15.25% Upside
 ·
CB
Chubb
 Jul 10, 2026 BUY Buy
-11.1% avg upside
32 analysts
$400.00
14.99% Upside
 ·
AII
American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.
 May 13, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+33.6% avg upside
7 analysts
$25.00
31.50% Upside
 +0.5%
LIFE
Ethos Technologies Inc. Class A
 May 07, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+28.6% avg upside
12 analysts
$27.00
34.42% Upside
 -36.0%
JRVR
James River Group
 May 05, 2026 HOLD Hold
+315.6% avg upside
7 analysts
 — -2.4%
LMND
Lemonade
 Apr 30, 2026 BUY Sell
-30.6% avg upside
22 analysts
$80.00
13.48% Upside
 -3.8%
AMSF
Amerisafe
 Apr 13, 2026 BUY Buy
+54.8% avg upside
4 analysts
$45.00
30.51% Upside
 +4.0%
ARX
Accelerant Holdings Class A
 Apr 13, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+55.4% avg upside
12 analysts
$17.00
34.40% Upside
 ·
BOW
Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc.
 Apr 13, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+1.9% avg upside
7 analysts
$35.00
11.49% Upside
 +28.1%
GSHD
GooseHead Insurance
 Apr 13, 2026 BUY Buy
+28.6% avg upside
15 analysts
$100.00
86.75% Upside
 +27.8%
KMPR
Kemper
 Feb 05, 2026 HOLD Hold
+122.6% avg upside
8 analysts
 — -10.2%
STC
Stewart Information Services
 Feb 02, 2026 BUY Strong Buy
+2.2% avg upside
5 analysts
$80.00
16.91% Upside
 +0.4%
SKWD
Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc.
 Dec 04, 2025 BUY Strong Buy
+5.3% avg upside
15 analysts
$80.00
34.79% Upside
 +26.0%
XZO
Exzeo Group, Inc.
 Dec 01, 2025 BUY Strong Buy
+52.6% avg upside
3 analysts
$27.00
58.53% Upside
 -28.0%
HCI
HCI Group
 Nov 10, 2025 BUY Buy
+6.1% avg upside
7 analysts
$255.00
39.71% Upside
 -2.9%
ACGL
Arch Capital Group
 Oct 14, 2025 BUY Buy
+5.3% avg upside
25 analysts
$125.00
23.60% Upside
 +9.6%
HIPO
Hippo Holdings
 Oct 14, 2025 BUY Strong Buy
+10.2% avg upside
9 analysts
$45.00
56.51% Upside
 -18.9%
HGTY
Hagerty Inc Class A
 Oct 01, 2025 BUY Hold
+8.3% avg upside
9 analysts
$15.00
22.68% Upside
 +1.3%
HRTG
Heritage Insurance Holdings
 Aug 28, 2025 HOLD Strong Buy
-0.2% avg upside
4 analysts
 — +24.9%
RLI
RLI
 Aug 28, 2025 HOLD Buy
+36.6% avg upside
14 analysts
 — -2.5%
KNSL
Kinsale Capital Group
 Jul 25, 2025 HOLD Hold
+6.6% avg upside
16 analysts
 — -28.5%
TRV
Travelers Companies
 Jul 21, 2025 HOLD Hold
-11.9% avg upside
33 analysts
 — +30.8%
SLDE
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc.
 Jul 14, 2025 BUY Strong Buy
+13.8% avg upside
6 analysts
$25.00
17.63% Upside
 +4.8%
HMN
Horace Mann Educators
 May 19, 2025 HOLD Buy
-6.0% avg upside
6 analysts
 — +8.4%
PLMR
Palomar Holdings
 May 06, 2025 HOLD Strong Buy
+2.7% avg upside
10 analysts
 — -29.2%
RNR
Renaissancere Holdings
 Apr 24, 2025 HOLD Buy
-7.2% avg upside
24 analysts
 — +36.4%
ROOT
Root
 Feb 27, 2025 HOLD Hold
-16.8% avg upside
18 analysts
 — -58.1%
EIG
Employers Holdings
 Feb 21, 2025 HOLD Strong Buy
-2.3% avg upside
4 analysts
 — -17.7%
RYAN
Ryan Specialty Group
 Feb 21, 2025 HOLD Buy
+18.3% avg upside
24 analysts
 — +5.7%
AXS
Axis Capital
 Feb 03, 2025 HOLD Buy
-1.0% avg upside
16 analysts
 — +17.3%
SIGI
Selective Insurance Group
 Jan 30, 2025 HOLD Buy
-4.1% avg upside
10 analysts
 — +4.3%
ORI
Old Republic International
 Jan 23, 2025 HOLD Buy
+1.4% avg upside
3 analysts
 — +13.9%
ALL
Allstate
 Feb 21, 2023 HOLD Buy
-17.3% avg upside
34 analysts
 — +22.0%
ACIC
American Coastal Insurance
 Aug 01, 2022 HOLD Buy
-6.4% avg upside
5 analysts
 — +388.2%
UBER
Uber Technologies
 Oct 09, 2019 BUY Strong Buy
+24.9% avg upside
64 analysts
$50.00
32.96% Downside
 +28.2%
KG
Kestrel Group
 May 15, 2018 HOLD Buy
-46.3% avg upside
4 analysts
$8.00
21.85% Downside
 -90.2%
🔒 34 more ratings — with price targets, crowd consensus and our measured returns.
Sign in free to unlock See Pro plans
Free account unlocks every analyst's full coverage table.
Matthew Carletti — Frequently Asked Questions
How accurate are Matthew Carletti's stock ratings?
Based on the calls 13Foresight could measure, about 67% of Matthew's ratings were profitable over a one-year hold, with an average return of +10.6% per rating, or -3.7% versus the S&P 500. We score every analyst the same way, from historical prices.
How is Matthew ranked on 13Foresight?
Matthew Carletti is currently ranked #1382 with a 3-star rating. Our rank blends hit rate, average return versus the market, and how many calls we have to judge — so a long, consistent record outweighs a few lucky picks. It is our own calculation, updated daily.
Which stocks does Matthew cover?
Matthew most recently has ratings on THG, HG, PLGO, BRO, CB, AII, LIFE, JRVR, LMND, AMSF, ARX, BOW and 27 more. See the full coverage table above for positions, price targets and our measured returns.
Where can I see other analyst ratings?
Browse the full analyst leaderboard to compare Wall Street analysts ranked by their measured performance, success rate and average return.

Disclaimer: 13Foresight compiles analyst ratings and price targets from publicly available sources. Performance metrics, rankings and star ratings shown here are calculated independently by 13Foresight from historical market prices and may differ from figures published elsewhere. This information may be incomplete, delayed or inaccurate, is provided for research and informational purposes only, and is not investment advice. The underlying ratings and opinions are those of the respective analysts and their firms; 13Foresight accepts no liability for any decisions made based on this data.